April 21, 2014

The Problems with Favoritism in Youth Sports Athletes

Sports parent Michael Sands is unhappy with what he calls favoritism at Beverly Hills High, where his son plays football.

The coaches are all volunteers, but on weekends, they coach certain kids—for a fee. This puts the young athletes who get extra coaching on weekends on a different playing field than those who don’t get the extra coaching, he says. They’re more likely to be favored by the coaches.

This type of scenario is common in youth sports. Sometimes, certain young athletes are invited to take part in summer sports camps, and they are more likely to get picked to play on their school teams. Of course, this is very hard on the kids who aren’t invited. It hurts their confidence.

But that’s not the only scenario that can hurt kids’ confidence. Certain young athletes are favored by their coaches even if there is no outside coaching. The coaches may like these kids’ attitude, or physical prowess, or may be influenced by what other adults say about these kids.

If you feel your athlete’s confidence is suffering because of these kinds of favoritism, there are a number of things you can do.

First of all, you can talk to the coach. But you have to be very careful about how you approach him or her.

Find a time when the coach is free and not distracted. Avoid talking to a coach right after a game. Be polite.

Don’t accuse the coach of favoritism or put the coach on the defensive. You might simply ask what you can do to ensure your child improves enough to get more playing time, or to make the team.

It’s also really important for your young athletes to learn how to cope with the reality of favoritism. Your athletes need to learn how to stop making comparisons with other kids—even if the coach favors these other kids.

Instead of focusing on the child favored by the coach, your athletes need to focus on themselves. They should identify their strengths, and concentrate on them.

What’s more, your athletes should not assume people are judging them, analyzing them, or talking about them.

You athletes should concentrate on themselves and improving their skills. In addition, kids should not try to play or perform like the favored athletes. They need to be themselves and take advantage of their strengths.

Want to learn more about how to improve your parenting skills and ensure your kids get the most of their talent?

At Kids’ Sports Psychology, we have loads of resources for you, including the following e-books. If you’re already an exclusive Kids’ Sports Psychology member, you can access them for free: They include:

  • Appreciate Your Talents: How to Avoid Making Comparisons and Intimidating Yourself (for sports kids
  • Growing From Adversity: How to Stay Confident after Failure (for sports kids)
  • Building Self-Confidence in Sports—for Kids 10 and Under
  • 7 Strategies to Help Sports Kids Stay Composed after Making Mistakes

But that’s not all. At Kids’ Sports Psychology, you can download more than 17 e-books—some written for parents and some specifically for sports kids.

You can also access audio and video programs that improve your sports parenting skills and boost kids’ confidence. Help your sports kids reap all the physical, emotional and social benefits of taking part in sports:

Kids’ Sports Psychology

Sincerely,

Patrick Cohn, Ph.D. and Lisa Cohn

P.S. If you’re already a Kids’ Sports Psychology member, you can visit this page to download our “Appreciate Your Talents” e-book:

“Appreciate Your Talents” e-book

Share

Comments

  1. My son has played select sports since he was 9. Why is it that there are some players the coaches favor because of daddy’s last name? Every team we have participated in seems to have the same recurring theme, it’s not what you know, it’s who you know. Bottom line, what I have learned, as a parent, is that your son may be the most talented, the fastest and earned his position, only to have a coach crush his efforts by giving, and I mean giving, the starting position/playing time to a less deserving player simply because of who the parents are.

    Kids get to an age when they begin to question and understand the “adult political game”. I’m not going to lie to my son when he asks “Why is … starting in my position when I’ve completed more passes, carried more yards and run faster?” Now at 13, he understands right from wrong and hard work makes a person better. We are trying to teach him that he must earn respect and reward, that it is not something that is just given away, although these coaches keep proving us wrong.

    I really don’t want to sound bitter, because I love watching my son play but every single coach has lied to us or went back on their word only to self-satisfy relationships with those who may benefit his agenda. It’s really sad and has only taught my son to cautiously trust his coaches.

  2. Frustrated says:

    Favoritism is a big issue with my daughter’s high school tennis team. Unfortunately, the coach year after year chooses the athletes for the varsity team based on their parents. If the parent helps during practice then special consideration is given to that athlete. Some of these athletes have horrible attitudes and don’t even want to be on the team, but are only there because of their parents. It’s sad when my daughter does everything the coach asks, has a good attitude and then is passed over for another athlete. It’s very hard to explain why this happens. It’s a definite blow to her confidence. My answer is to not complain to the coach (yet – I would like to have some conversation with him about why she’s been passed over), but become more active in the parent side. School athletic meetings, practices, etc. This is a hard lesson for my daughter, but does happen in the outside world quite a bit.

  3. Ralph , Raplh A says:

    My Son played basketball from age 8, being tall he was selected to play as a Center by his coaches and he has been always a starter at the Middle school & High school. My son played for travel teams and all big academy’s and spent most of his time playing basketball, as this sport is his passion, We as a parent always supported him. He was well liked by most parents and coaches because of his sharp basketball skills and always considered the best on the team.

    Every parent’s dream is to see their son’s & daughter get successful in their goals. Since my son was good in basketball he was selected on the Varsity team while he was a junior but a setback happen to him when he hurt his neck after a month into the season and was advised by the Doctors to hold on for this season. My son came back on the varsity team in senior years, but he was put to play on the junior Varsity, inspite of having height of 6.6 and having tremendous skills in the basketball., and to add insult to injury , when Varsity poster was published, he was put right behind the juniors and sophomores in the Varsity poster> Its very sad to see this kid a lot of time on this sport and work very hard , he didn’t get any respect. As a parents we are very heart broken, any advise?

  4. It’s very uncomfortable to watch when your child, being the most talented, and hearing this reiterated by hundreds on parents, officials, college coaches and school staff is made to stand by quarter after quarter because the under-classman with the favored last name is playing the starting spot. Whatever you do, don’t send your child to a private school and expect to play unless they have the household last name. This has to stop. I’m just figuring out how to do it. The stats and the videos don’t lie, but coaches do.

  5. I have a hard time agreeing with this article as it seems to explain how to lessen favoritism or attempt to lessen the psychological damage that is caused by favoritism rather than stamping it out at it’s roots. Every one wants to win But there is no I in Team or sports for that matter. Why are there no rules put in place at the high school level to guarantee equal playing time for every team member? how does someone improve by warming a bench? If players are not good enough to play why were they allowed on the team in the first place. Wouldn’t it be more humane to deny acceptance initially rather than forcing them to warm a bench most of the time and not allowing them on the field or court during championships. and if not, then exactly how many times is sufficient during a season to tell a child how they fall short of the mark for whatever reason? Favoritism is ugly and in my opinion is a form of organized, accepted bulling. No child should ever experience it. Favoritism should and can be easily stopped but there does not seem to be a will to do that. In my opinion team spirit is every bit as important as skill but what team spirit can exist in a team that practices favoritism? very few children Will ever become pro or semi pro so why do we have sports if not to teach teamwork? Team work teaches us that we win or lose as a team and that sometimes we have to sacrifice ourselves for the team. My final question is this? What does favoritism teach our kids?

    While kids need to learn that for the win they may have to sacrifice themselves for the team they must also learn that the team may need to sacrifice the win to be fair. if it is fair win or lose if you feel good about it then it is a Victory to all but those who support favoritism.

  6. momma anderson says:

    I share the sentiment of many of you who posted, and have experience many of the same things you are talking about. Our daughter will soon finish her high school career and has learned more life lessons about favoritism, bullying, disparity, gossip, motives and nepotism in the basketball gym than anywhere else in her life. I am not sure that I can say that keeping her in team sports at her school was a good move. I don’t mean to imply that all coaches exhibit those attitudes, but it does seem more prevalent as kids get older. High school sports have very little to do with creating self improvement, esteem or motivation. It’s a different world from what it was when we played 20 or 30 years ago, and the remnants of what is left is very disappointing. At a recent parent meeting, the coach said “we don’t play potential”. Problem is, he doesn’t encourage it either. With that said, I still consider my highschool coaches among my favorite people in the world – and I wished my kid had that feeling.

  7. Momma Anderson,
    Thanks for sharing your story. I do hope that your story is more of an exception than the rule. We want kids to reap the many benefits of participating in youth sports. As you say, the coaches are critical, and we want all young athletes to remember their coaches the way you remember yours.

    –Lisa

  8. Favoritism exists at all levels of our society, from the lowest level you can think of up to the president choosing cabinet members. That is one reason incompetence rears its ugly head. Why you ask yourself sometimes: how did that guy get there? He must have connections. And the children being favored? They will carry on the tradition because they have seen it work. So if you are a victim of favoritism, maybe you don’t even know it, then produce performance grades that can not be denied. And good luck with that.

Speak Your Mind

*